Total Pageviews

Tuesday, 2 September 2008

Summer Stories -Daniel E. Rosan, Malawi


Days in rural Malawi begin just before dawn. Children start fetching water from the taps in the foyer of our guest house. The bakery run by HIV-positive women out of our kitchen is up and running a few minutes later. And the cook has begun slaughtering a goat for dinner.

I am at the Partners in Health guest house in Neno, in the heart of Malawi's poor, mountainous border region, in the heart of Africa. Today, I rush through the ice-cold shower, notice the electricity is out again, and head to the hospital to spend the day with the pharmacy team delivering malaria medicines to health centers even more remote than we are.

That day ended with an emergency, a community health worker ill with cerebral malaria whom we found being carried by her family the 20km from her home to the hospital. We put her in our Land Rover and she was successfully treated. It drove home the stakes - good supply chains here are a matter of life and death.

HBS students travel the world for their summer internships, but I would argue none were farther from paved roads or supermarkets than I was in Neno. Partners in Health, an international health delivery organization which operates in nine countries, has just begun operations here in a partnership with the Clinton Foundation and the Malawian Ministry of Health. The main hospital is not yet open, but already over 1,000 patients are on life-saving antiretroviral AIDS drugs. They asked me to serve as an internal consultant focused on food and drug costs. In the process, I got to live and work with an incredible collection of American and Malawian staff who have moved far from their homes to lift this district out of poverty.

There were some missteps along the way - such as my hubristic attempt to help a friend make mud bricks for his mothers' new house (bottom line: I am bad at making bricks). But overall living in a close-knit rural community was a privilege, and it came with real insight into how development really happens.

To describe PIH as only a health care provider is to fundamentally misunderstand its development role. In Neno, the soil is poor, the roads are bad, and the vast majority of inhabitants have no running water, indoor plumbing, or electricity. PIH is therefore not just the only health care option, it is an economic driver. PIH employs 300 people, a huge number in an area where the economy is based on subsistence farming. PIH runs the largest vehicle fleet in a district where even the ubiquitous minibus is a rare sight. PIH buys hundreds of thousands of dollars of food, feeds staff and patients alike, and is building housing, warehouses, clinics, hospitals, even septic systems.

Outside the main hospital, women sell cell phone airtime, men offer rides on their bicycles for a few kwacha, families run market stalls with bananas and mangos (in season), and a bus has even begun to make the 3.5 hour run to the nearest major city, Blantyre. These services are there because patients, their families, and PIH staff demand those services. For the patients I spoke to, PIH is about health care. But for others, PIH is about job creation and the development of a cash economy. What began as two American doctors and one HBS MBA (class of 2006) is now an economic engine for the whole district.

PIH asked me to function as an internal consultant, addressing a wide variety of problems related to procurement and supply chain management. I did everything from train commercial sex workers in basic accounting to analyze patient flow at the laboratory. But most of my time was focused on two main projects: food aid procurement and pharmaceutical supply chain management.

Uniquely among global health providers, PIH provides each HIV and TB patient with food aid. The food is a porridge of cornmeal, soy, vitamins, and sugar, along with cooking oil. The impact is tremendous. Sick patients fight a constant battle against malnutrition, whose only real cure is food. Giving food also improves compliance with treatment regimes. Patients are more likely to keep their appointments if they will also be getting food for a month. And of course, taking toxic AIDS drugs on an empty stomach is practically impossible.

Currently, PIH buys food from international companies. As global food prices soar, PIH's costs do as well. Neno's local farmers should be getting the benefit of rising prices but are shut out because of the poor infrastructure. I developed a business plan for buying from local farmers, processing the food aid, and distributing it to patients. The strategy lowered PIH's overall food aid costs but re-directed spending to local farmers. The second project unraveled PIH's complicated pharmaceutical supply chain. Working with local staff, I developed a new information flow which will eliminate stock-outs while lowering inventory costs and reducing paperwork.

On a personal level, working in Malawi for the summer was probably the single most difficult experience in my life. But to any HBS student looking to spend the summer outside of a cubicle, look to places such as Malawi. The impact is real, and really makes a difference.

Double blow for Malawi


Malawi’s Russel Mwafulirwa and Esau Kanyenda are ruled out of this Friday’s 2010 World Cup preliminary qualifier against Djibouti.

Former Ajax Cape Town striker Mwafulirwa will miss the away game due to an injury he sustained at Swedish side IFK Norrkoping.

On the other hand, the ‘Black Mamba’ (Kanyenda) is also recovering from an injury at his Russian First Division side, KamaZ.

The absence of the two key strikers has left coach Kinnah Phiri in near desperation.

The former Free State Stars coach will now bank on Bay United striker Jimmy Zakazaka, who was usually used as a substitute in the early group 12 games that saw Malawi beat Egypt 1-0, Djibouti 8-1 before succumbing 2-0 to the Pharaohs and 1-0 to DRC.

Another notable face missing in the squad which left Saturday for Djibouti via Ethiopia is transfer-listed Moroka Swallows’ midfielder Hellings Mwakasungula.


Kinnah explained Mwakasungula’s omission to KickOff.com.

“He last called me when he was training with Mpumalanga Black Aces and since then I haven’t heard from him, so it was difficult for me to call him,” he said.

The Flames’ squad also comprise Dynamos keeper Swadick Sanudi, Orlando Pirates’ Joseph Kamwendo, Bloemfontein Celtics’ Fischer Kondowe, Black Leopards’ Robert Ng’ambi, Peter Mponda and Santos’ Tawonga Chimodzi.

Defender James Sangala has also made the trip despite being clubless after being released by Thanda Zulu Royals.

Phiri has hailed also Orlando Pirates new Dutch coach Ruud Krol for giving Kamwendo more game time.

Kinnah says the Flames stand to benefit if the winger is given a fair chance to prove himself at club level, having endured a torrid time under departed Owen da Gama.

“When he came for the June 2010 World Cup preliminary qualifiers the player looked down lacking a little bit of confidence. I had to sit down with him and made him believe he is still the quality player. I’m glad he has re-discovered his spark,” Kinnah told KickOff.com.

Kamwendo had a grand game when he scored in 8-1 whacking of Djibouti in June then carried on his form with a Man of the Match display in an historic 1-0 win over reigning Africa kings Egypt.

The dreadlocked winger, who was rocked with injuries in his debut season at Pirates, has shown flashes of brilliance that earned his move to Danish giants Norrdsjaelland two years ago after signing from Zimbabwe’s Caps United.

And Kinnah believes the best is yet to come from the sweet-passing playmaker.

Malawi Ex-President Seeks to Overturn Treason Allegations

Malawi's former president is seeking to have the treason allegation leveled against him by President Bingu Wa Mutharika's administration thrown out of court. Attorneys for Ex-President Bakili Muluzi contend that the government has so far failed to start court proceedings to formally charge the former president three months after he was arrested. Ralph Kasambara is the lead attorney of former President Muluzi. He tells reporter Peter Clottey from the commercial capital, Blantyre that President Mutharika's administration is not serious about the allegations against Muluzi.

"What we are seeking from the court is that the present allegations and all charges against the former head of state Dr. Muluzi dropped. The basis for that motion is that since he was arrested by the police over three months ago now, the police have not preferred any treason charges against him…or indeed process the issue of bail. But they didn't do that and they kept on saying that they (police) were still investigating and afterwards they will determine whether to prefer charges of treason against him or not," Kasambara pointed out.

He said the court has made its ruling very clear on the specificity within which the government was supposed to formally charge the former president.

"Now the court had made an order that after three months if there was no movement of the case, we were free to approach the court to vary the bail condition. So, we think this is not the case of carrying the bail condition because when you talk of bail where somebody is accused of having committed an offense, you have got a case where Dr. Muluzi is not even accused of committing an offense," he said.

Kasambara said the former president's case to have the treason allegations dropped would be upheld by the court.

"Definitely the court will agree with us and I'm sure go ahead to make some scathing remarks against the prosecution because that is not how you do it. You can't arrest somebody, you don't prefer charges against him, and you don't take him before court for any charges and just stay three months doing nothing. And that is not prosecution, it is persecution," Kasambara noted.

He describes President Mutharika's government as unprepared to press treason charges against the former president.

"Let's understand here that the charges we are dealing with are not served from a shop, whatever charges of trying to usurp state powers and trying to take over government. And when they were asked in court if they had evidence, they brought in some anonymous letters, and the court quashed them there and then in Lilongwe. And now that was very telling to the prosecution that guys you are not up to it, if you are going to ride on this kind of evidence then forget it. Don't even dream of it. Now those were the charges leveled against the Brigadier generals, two weeks when they were arresting Muluzi surely they couldn't base it on the very same evidence that has already been quashed by the court," he said.

Kasambara described the government's move to charge the former president of treason as a fraught attempt to silence Mr. Muluzi.

"Now this is a desperate attempt by the current administration to cling to something that they understand does not make sense. And that amounts to political persecution rather than prosecution," Kasambara pointed out.

He said the former president would soon file a civil suit to serve as a deterrent for public officials to desist from abusing their offices.

"Once we have the court agree with us and the allegations thrown out, then we would go forward and file a civil action against the administration and against the government and the individuals that were involved. We think it is high time that individual public officers are there to enforce the law and not to abuse the law. I mean this is not the first time that the former president has been harassed by the state machinery. Just about last week he was denied his constitutional rights of conducting public rallies," he said.

Muluzi was alleged to have conspired with military officers and some executive members of the opposition United Democratic Front to overthrow President Bingu Wa Mutharika's administration. He was arrested in May on allegations of plotting to overthrow President Mutharika's administration shortly after returning to the country from a trip to the United Kingdom. But former President Muluzi has denied the allegations.